Serves the Commercial Small Fleet Market of 10 – 50 Vehicles

Which Models Favor a Short Cycle?

August 2005, by Chris Brown, Senior Editor

The longer you keep a vehicle in service the lower its net depreciation expense, right? Not always. In our Mar/Apr 05 issue we presented a few makes and models that disprove the prevailing wisdom. (“Will Keeping Vehicles Longer Lower Depreciation Expense?”) We’ve expanded the study to encompass more vehicles and study their net depreciation costs over 24, 36 and 48 months.We’ve uncovered more models in which monthly depreciation expense over two or three years is about equal or less than over four years. These models are good candidates for “short cycling,” i.e., retaining them for less than the usual number of months of service life. Looking at whole segments, minivans and smaller SUVs have the most models in our study group with depreciation rates favorable for short cycling. Study ParametersWe priced all models at invoice minus fleet incentives. We used Black Book, a used-vehicle guide, to determine residual values for each model at 24, 36 and 48 months. We assumed 2,000 miles a month and accumulated mileage of 48,000 at 24 months, 72,000 at 36 months and 96,000 at 48 months. High mileage was deducted accordingly.The chart illustrates the results. Each model shows an estimated two-, three- and four-year depreciation expense amount and average monthly net depreciation amounts at 24, 36 and 48 months.Open and print this chart for the story: Compact SedansFive of the six compact models reviewed achieved their lowest depreciation expense by retaining them for four years. These models depreciated at a fairly even slope from two to four years. The exception was the Hyundai Elantra GLS. Its average net depreciation at 24 months was $171, substantially lower than at 36 months ($198) and even lower than 48 months ($186). Intermediate SedansThe intermediates depreciated less predictably. Another Hyundai, the Sonata GL, is a good candidate for two-year short cycling ($207 at 24 months, $228/36, and $212/48). Other models look good for two- over three-year retention. The Ford Taurus and its twin, the Mercury Sable, depreciated less per month after two years than three. The Mitsubishi Galant DE and Buick Century Custom suffer only slight drops in monthly depreciation from two to three years. The Honda Accord LX is a contender for three- over four-year retention: it depreciates $233 a month at 24 months but levels off at $200 for 36 and 48 months.Full-Size SedansOne model in this group achieved a lower depreciation expense at two years versus three and four—the fleet-popular Chevrolet Impala ($225/24, $258/36 and $246/48). The other models depreciated evenly.MinivansFive out of 10 models in the minivan category emerged as potential short-cyclers. The Honda Odyssey LX is a prime contender. Its average monthly depreciation expense worked out to a miserly $80 per month over 24 months and 48,000 miles, then dropped to $148 at 36 months and $186 at 48 months—over twice the depreciation than at 24 months. The Toyota Sienna CE, Chrysler Town & Country, Dodge Caravan SE and Nissan Quest also fared better at two years over four. The Nissan Quest and GMC Safari dropped less than $4 in average monthly depreciation from two to four years. {+PAGEBREAK+}Pickup TrucksThe Toyota Tacoma is the only model of the four small/medium pickups studied to have a lower depreciation at 24 months than at 48 months. However, four of the five full-size pick-ups have a lower depreciation expense at 24 months compared to 48. Mid-Size SUVsOf 10 mid-size SUV models reviewed, eight achieved our lower 24-month depreciation expense. The Toyota Highlander has the distinction of achieving a Black Book-Clean value at 24 months that exceeds its original invoice cost. The Highlander enjoys a generous fleet incentive while holding a very strong residual value. In reality you won’t find a two-year-old Highlander worth more than a new one. Yet the Black Book numbers—as well as other vehicle price guides—testify to this vehicle’s very good value.It Pays to Study DepreciationStudying any vehicle’s estimated depreciation expense pays off in two areas. First, certain models can be identified as being viable candidates for two- or three-year retention over four. Of the 52 models in the study, we found 21 that had a lower average monthly depreciation cost at 24 months. Six more models were a few dollars off. We’ve found the majority of the short-cycle candidates fall within the minivan, full-size pickup and SUV categories.Second, be it at 24-, 36- or 48-month cycles, there are considerable overall net depreciation expense differences between models. Vehicles that have lower monthly depreciation values earlier in their lifecycle don’t necessarily offer the best overall value—their values have simply declined more irregularly than the normal pattern.To close we’ll repeat one of our mantras in Business Fleet: It pays to analyze the total cost of ownership of a vehicle, not just the initial cost.
Twitter Facebook Google+


Please note that comments may be moderated. 
Leave this field empty:

Fleet Incentives

Determine the actual cost of owning and running a vehicle in your fleet. Compare vehicles by class and model.


Fleet Faq Fuel Management

Bernie Kanavagh from WEX will answer your questions and challenges

View All


Fleet Tracking And Telematics

Todd Ewing from Fleetmatics will answer your questions and challenges

View All


Fleet Management And Leasing

Jack Firriolo from Merchants will answer your questions and challenges

View All


Sponsored by

Greg Tarring worked as fleet manager at Phillip Morris.

Read more


Market Trends

Mike Antich
Why Competent Fleet Managers Are Terminated

By Mike Antich
Over the years, I have known many competent fleet managers. But, like salmons swimming upstream, not every promising fleet manager survives the challenges and rigors of day-to-day fleet management. It is understandable when fleet managers are fired for making expensive mistakes or when caught engaging in ethical transgressions, but, sadly, many more are terminated for circumstances that are entirely avoidable.

Forces Threaten to Change Fleet From a Career to a Stepping Stone

By Mike Antich

View All

Driving Notes

Chris Brown
Hyundai Ioniq Plug-in Hybrid

By Chris Brown
The Hyundai Ioniq Plug-in Hybrid is the least expensive model on the market to offer electric-only range, while offering spirited driving performance and plenty of standard features.

2018 Range Rover Velar First Edition

By Mike Antich

View All

Nobody Asked Me, But...

Sherb Brown
Keep Realistic Fleet Expectations

By Sherb Brown
If you don’t stay on top of the latest developments in mobility, battery technology, autonomous vehicles, and telematics, you are subjecting yourself to the whims of senior management who may be making decisions based on the latest trendy news.

Fleet Management 2.0

By Sherb Brown

View All

Auto Focus

Chris Brown
What a Connected Fleet Means to Avis (and Car Rental)

By Chris Brown
Counter bypass is just the beginning. The promise of a “data-driven ecosystem” that connects renters with the rental agency, retail services, and even the city is a better managed fleet, an improved user experience, and new revenue opportunities during the rental itself.

Should Peer-to-Peer Renters Pay Airport Car Rental Fees?

By Chris Brown

View All


Up Next

More From The World's Largest Fleet Publisher