Biodiesel, a form of diesel fuel produced from vegetable oils or animal fats, is the only alternative fuel that runs in any conventional diesel engine. As such, biodiesel offers a straightforward path to a greener fleet.
Manufactured domestically, bio-diesel cuts emissions of carbon monoxide, sulfur, smog-producing particulate matter and carbon dioxide - the main greenhouse gas causing global warming.
Through rigorous standards, testing and evaluation, biodiesel has shed its early misperception as a vegetable oil "homebrew." Still, there are challenges to implementation: limited retail availability, fluctuating pump prices, maintenance and performance concerns and vehicle warranty issues. Here's a how-to guide to determine if biodiesel will work in your fleet.
Know the Standards
Biodiesel is blended with petroleum diesel for most retail fuel applications. Common blends are B2 (2 percent biodiesel), B5, B20 and B100 (pure biodiesel).
B20 is the most commonly used biodiesel blend in the United States. This blend provides a good balance between material compatibility, cold weather operability, performance, emission benefits and costs, according to the National Renewable Energy Laboratory.
Standards development body ASTM International sets minimum accepted values for fuel properties. The standard for petroleum diesel fuel is ASTM D975, while ASTM D6751 covers pure biodiesel (B100) for blending with petro diesel in levels up to 20 percent by volume.
Today, biodiesel must meet the ASTM D6751 standard to be legally defined and sold at retail fueling stations. Further, producers and marketers of biodiesel have created a voluntary accreditation program of biodiesel fuel. BQ-9000 is a quality systems program for biodiesel storage, sampling, testing, blending, shipping, distribution and fuel management.
Though these quality checks and balances are the industry rule, it is a good idea to confirm through documentation that your supplier adheres to accepted standards and accreditation, says Steven J. Levy, managing director of Sprague Energy, a supplier of traditional and alternative fuels.
Check Engine Warranty
Check your vehicle engine manufacturers' warranty statements on biodiesel. Note that parts failures resulting from the use of any fuel are not covered.
Currently, most engine manufacturers state the use of up to B5 will not void warranties, provided the fuel meets ASTM standards.
Chrysler, Cummins, Ford, General Motors and International/Navistar have certified certain models for B20. Other enginemakers are "currently completing research for B20 support," according to the National Bio-diesel Board (NBB) Web site, www.biodiesel.org, which lists warranty statements for most manufacturers.
Fleets regularly use higher blends not covered in OEM warranty statements. While this runs the risk of voiding a warranty, fleet managers concentrate on the quality of the biodiesel to safeguard against parts failures.
Jim Evanoff, environmental protection specialist for Yellowstone National Park, says his supplier conducts his own tests in addition to ASTM certification. "We don't give it a thought, to be honest," Evanoff says. "We've never had a warranty issue." The park has been using varying blends of biodiesel for 15 years.
The New York City Department of Sanitation has been running B5 for five years in close to 6,000 vehicles and started a B20 pilot test in November 2009. Rocco DiRico, deputy commissioner for the Bureau of Support Services, reports no issues with engine malfunctions related to biodiesel.
Find It, Price It
The NBB Web site lists biodiesel distributors and 1,337 retail fueling locations nationwide in list and map format.
The Midwest has the most retail fueling stations; Illinois lists 151 records. The Northeast has limited coverage at present; only 15 stations are listed in the state of New York. With the introduction of and recent revisions to the EPA's Renewable Fuel Standard, which sets mandatory lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions thresholds for renewable fuel categories, biodiesel will likely become more readily available at retail service stations, according to Levy.
If your area has limited retail fueling stations, one option is to investigate on-site tank installation and delivery. However, this may not make sense for small fleet applications.
"There are a whole slew of hidden costs for having your own pump," says Levy. "You could save a nickel per gallon [for bulk fuel distribution], but the cost to maintain the tank may far outweigh the savings."
In addition to installation, Levy points out costs such as tank maintenance, administrative overhead, managing inventory and environmental compliance. Amortizing those costs for an on-road, centrally fueled fleet using 100,000 gallons a month may be worth the tank installation; for fleets needing 10,000 gallons a month, it may not make sense. "And you always have the liability risk of leaky tanks," Levy says.
B20 has an average price per gallon that ranges from one cent less to 18 cents more than conventional diesel fuel on average, according to an April 2010 Clean Cities report.
Maintenance a Must
The initial switch from petroleum diesel to a biodiesel blend requires attention to fuel filters. Biodiesel has solvent properties that can loosen the petroleum diesel deposits that accumulate on tank walls and pipes, and a sudden influx of particles can clog fuel filters.
Evanoff says clogged filters were an issue on older vehicles with significant sludge buildup. "We increased the frequency of the filter change and monitored the situation more closely," Evanoff says. "Eventually, they clean themselves out."
DiRico manages the issue through strict preventive maintenance, which happens regardless of biodiesel concerns. Trucks are on a regular 40-day inspection cycle. Fuel filters are changed as needed but at intervals no longer than 250 engine hours.
Biodiesel can also soften or degrade natural rubber hoses and gaskets, leading to fuel leaks and spills. Engines built before 1993 should be checked and natural rubber parts replaced. Newer engines with synthetic rubber parts do not encounter this problem.
Yellowstone stores its biodiesel in 28 underground tanks around the park. Evanoff says that in-ground temperatures stay a constant 56 degrees, which is conducive to algae and bacterial growth, especially with water contamination.
DiRico's team has its in-ground tanks inspected yearly. Tank filters are changed every two months, whether it's needed or not. Checking filters - on the tank or the truck - is a good way to catch a problem before it develops, DiRico says.
If slight contamination is detected, the tank can be treated with an algicide and cleaned without having to be emptied. These issues can happen with any fuel, DiRico says.
On the plus side, biodiesel provides greater lubricity to engine parts, leading to less engine wear and extended engine life.
Cold Weather Gel?
One issue traditionally associated with biodiesel was its tendency to gel in cold temperatures and clog fuel lines quicker than petro diesel. These issues have largely been resolved with ASTM standardization and the implementation of specific blend formulations for cold weather climates.
Check with your fuel supplier to ensure the blend you're using is suitable for the environment.
"We've made it work here in Yellowstone with our severe climate and high elevation," says Evanoff.
Average Alternative Fuel Prices Nationwide - April 2010
Gasoline (regular): $2.84
Ethanol (E85): $2.42
Biodiesel (B20): $3.12
Biodiesel (B99-B100): $3.57
Source: Clean Cities Alternative Fuel Price Report