Business Fleet Logo

Top-Rated Head Restraints Cut Injuries by 11%

A new study from two affiliated insurance industry groups highlights progress in the prevention of whiplash in rear-end crashes.

November 30, 2015
Top-Rated Head Restraints Cut Injuries by 11%

 

Photo: IIHS

2 min to read


Vehicle seat/head restraint combinations earning top scores from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety reduce injury claim rates by 11.2 percent, compared to vehicles with poorly rated restraint combinations, a new study found.

The study, released by IIHS and the Highway Loss Data Institute, concluded that top-rated restraint combinations markedly reduce the likelihood that someone will sustain neck injuries if rear-ended by another vehicle.

Ad Loading...

The study also underscored the dramatic improvement in such restraint quality in today’s vehicles. A decade ago, IIHS said, more than half of the seat/head restraints the institute evaluated were rated “poor” and just 9 percent drew a “good” score. In contrast, 95 percent of 2015 models earned a “good” rating and none were rated “poor.” IIHS credited its own ratings program, combined with stricter federal requirements for higher front-seat head restraints, for the overall improvement in such occupant protection.

IIHS rates such vehicle restraints as “good,” “acceptable,” “marginal,” or “poor” based on both front-seat head restraint geometry and test results. (To learn more about these test methods, click on the photo or link below the headline to watch an IIHS video from 2013.)

In the U.S., whiplash injuries are the most frequently reported type of injury resulting from crashes.

For the recent study, researchers used an insurance claim database of more than 600,000 rear-impact crashes to assess the likelihood of an associated injury claim. IIHS and HLDI based study results on 2001-2014 model-year cars and SUVs using property damage liability and personal injury protection claims.

“The injury-reduction benefits were greatest for good-rated seats/head restraints,” IIHS reported. “Those with acceptable or marginal ratings had injury rates that were 4.4 percent and 3.7 percent lower, respectively, than seats/head restraints rated poor.”

Ad Loading...

The safety benefit of higher-quality restraints was even more pronounced among women, who saw lower injury rates with “good,” “acceptable,” and “marginal”-rated seats compared with “poor”-rated seats. For men, only “good”-rated seats were tied to statistically lower injury rates.

Females are believed to be at a higher risk for neck injuries because of several physical differences, the study noted.

“Injury rates were 13 percent lower for women and 9 percent lower for men in vehicles with good-rated seats/head restraints,” IIHS said.

Originally posted on Automotive Fleet

More Safety

Bar chart showing fleets with 10 or fewer vehicles monitor 25% of their vehicles with telematics, compared with 90% for fleets with 11 to 99 vehicles.
Safety•by Lauren Fletcher•October 1, 2026

Small Fleets Lag in Telematics Coverage as Industry Moves Beyond Adoption

SambaSafety’s 2026 Telematics Report finds fleets with 10 or fewer vehicles monitor a much smaller share of their vehicles than larger operations, as the industry shifts its focus from collecting data to using it.

Read More →
Business Fleet back-to-school graphic featuring a yellow school bus traveling on a highway under a blue sky.
Safety•by Lauren Fletcher•September 28, 2026

Back-to-School Traffic Is Not the Risk Fleets Think It Is

Back-to-school traffic does not always mean more crashes. New Empiric Earth data shows why fleets should focus on when and where risk changes.

Read More →
Worker drives a company vehicle with safety gear, tools, and a daily vehicle inspection checklist visible inside the cab.
Safety•September 23, 2026

Small Fleet, Big Exposure: How to Reduce Workers’ Comp Risks

For small fleets, one crash can trigger far more than vehicle damage. Here’s how stronger driver safety policies, training, maintenance, and technology can help reduce workers’ comp exposure.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Snow-covered road through a winter forest with the words “Are You Prepared?” across the sky.
Safety•by Lauren Fletcher•September 14, 2026

Who Makes the Call When Winter Weather Gets Dangerous?

Winter weather can quickly change a small fleet’s plans. Knowing when to reroute, delay, or stop can matter just as much as preparing the vehicles themselves.

Read More →
Fuel nozzle positioned near a vehicle’s open fuel filler as blue static electricity arcs between the nozzle and fill point.
Safety•by Staff•August 31, 2026

API Issues Refueling Safety Guidelines

The American Petroleum Institute offers a list of safe vehicle refueling guidelines, including ways to avoid potential problems with static electricity discharges in fall, winter, and early spring.

Read More →
Winter emergency kit with gloves, flashlight, snow brush, and cold-weather supplies arranged on snowy ground during falling snow.
Safety•by Staff•August 26, 2026

Winter Fleet Prep: Expert Tips to Keep Vehicles Running Smoothly

Cold weather can expose weak batteries, tires, fuel systems, and maintenance gaps fast. Use this winter fleet checklist to prepare trucks and drivers before temperatures drop.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Technician wearing safety glasses inspects a front-mounted ADAS radar sensor on a blue commercial truck.
Safety•by Lauren Fletcher•July 15, 2026

8 ADAS Maintenance Tips for Small Business Fleets From Bendix

A dirty camera, bad alignment, or one loose connection could quietly knock your fleet’s ADAS offline. Here’s what Bendix says to check.

Read More →
 Drivers in a safety meeting at Wheelz Up
Safety•by Amy Hercher•July 14, 2026

Developing Budget-Friendly Driver Safety Programs

From driver training and safety meetings to one-on-one coaching and incentive programs, several small fleets share how they have developed a safety culture with their drivers using low- to no-cost resources.

Read More →
Business Fleet graphic promoting Operation Safe Driver Week, showing a police vehicle with flashing red and blue emergency lights and the dates July 12-18, 2026.
Safety•by Lauren Fletcher•July 2, 2026

A 20-Minute Safety Check for Small Fleets Before Operation Safe Driver Week

No safety department? No problem. Here's a practical checklist small fleet managers can use before Operation Safe Driver Week begins.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A commercial vehicle wheel and an inspector holding a clipboard appear behind the headline "Getting Tripped Up?" highlighting fleet compliance and roadside inspection challenges.
Safety•by Lauren Fletcher•June 25, 2026

Why Small Fleets Keep Getting Tripped Up by ELD Compliance

Roadcheck revealed a hard truth: most ELD violations aren't intentional. They're caused by small mistakes that can cost fleets time, money, and trust.

Read More →